Do We Really Need Milk for Calcium? Rethinking Nutrition, Traditional Foods and Gut Health
Haven't we always been told that we need to drink milk to get enough calcium?
For generations, we've been encouraged to believe that dairy is the cornerstone of strong bones, healthy teeth and good nutrition. And while milk and dairy products are certainly sources of calcium, they aren't the only ones.
In fact, the natural world offers an abundance of calcium-rich foods, many of which have been part of traditional diets for thousands of years.
So, where does calcium actually come from?
It starts in the soil
Calcium is a naturally occurring mineral found in the earth's soil. Plants absorb it through their roots, and we obtain it by eating those plants, or by eating animals that have consumed them.
Think dark leafy greens, broccoli, kale, beans, almonds, sesame seeds and calcium-set tofu.
Cows don't manufacture calcium. They obtain it from their diet, just as we do.
The interesting thing is that our understanding of nutrition has traditionally focused heavily on individual nutrients: how much calcium, how much protein, how much vitamin C.
But good nutrition is about much more than simply ticking off numbers on a nutritional label.
It's about the quality of the food we eat, how it is prepared, how our bodies digest it and how effectively we absorb and utilise its nutrients.
It's not just what you eat. It's what your body can use.
Have you ever stopped to consider that eating a nutritious food and actually making use of its nutrients are two different things?
Nutrient bioavailability refers to the proportion of a nutrient that is digested, absorbed and made available for use by the body.
This can vary considerably depending on the food itself, its preparation and the presence of other dietary components.
For example, calcium from different plant foods has different absorption rates. Calcium from kale and broccoli is relatively well absorbed, while spinach contains calcium that is less bioavailable because of its high oxalate content.
This is one reason why looking beyond the nutritional label matters.
It's also why traditional food preparation methods deserve a closer look.
The forgotten wisdom of fermentation
Long before refrigeration, supermarkets and modern food manufacturing, fermentation was an essential part of how people preserved and prepared their food.
Across cultures, people fermented vegetables, grains, dairy products and drinks to extend shelf life, develop flavour and transform everyday ingredients.
Today, we're rediscovering why these traditional food practices are so relevant to modern wellness.
Fermentation is a natural process in which microorganisms, including beneficial bacteria and yeasts, break down sugars and other compounds in food.
Depending on the food and fermentation process, this can:
- Produce organic acids and other flavour compounds.
- Reduce certain antinutritional compounds, such as phytates, which can bind minerals and reduce their absorption.
- Transform some food components into forms that may be easier to digest.
- Introduce live microorganisms into foods and drinks when they are not subsequently pasteurised or otherwise treated to eliminate them.
For example, fermenting vegetables into sauerkraut or kimchi can transform their flavour, texture and nutritional composition. Fermented dairy products such as kefir and yoghurt also offer a different nutritional profile from their unfermented counterparts.
Fermentation doesn't magically make every nutrient more available, and the effects depend on the ingredients and process. But it is an important part of the wider conversation about food quality, digestion and nutrition.
Your gut is part of the bigger picture
One of the most exciting areas of modern nutritional science is our growing understanding of the gut microbiome.
Your digestive system is home to trillions of microorganisms, collectively known as the gut microbiota. These microorganisms play important roles in digestion, metabolism, immune function and the production of certain beneficial compounds.
And what we eat helps shape this complex ecosystem.
A varied diet rich in plant foods provides dietary fibre and other compounds that can support beneficial gut microorganisms.
Fermented foods can also contribute to dietary diversity by providing live microorganisms, depending on how they are made and stored.
Research published in the journal Cell in 2021 found that a diet high in fermented foods increased microbiome diversity and reduced several inflammatory markers in a small study of healthy adults.
It's an encouraging finding and part of a growing body of research exploring the relationship between fermented foods and human health.
This doesn't mean fermented foods are a cure-all, or that everyone needs to consume large quantities. Rather, they offer another delicious way to introduce variety into an already balanced diet.
A more holistic approach to modern nutrition
So, do we need milk for calcium?
No. Dairy is one dietary source of calcium, but certainly not the only one. A well-planned diet can meet calcium requirements through a combination of plant and other food sources.
For those who consume dairy, fermented options such as kefir and yoghurt can be valuable additions. For those who prefer plant-based alternatives, calcium-set tofu, leafy greens, fortified plant milks, beans, nuts and seeds can all contribute.
But perhaps the bigger lesson is that nutrition shouldn't be reduced to a single food, nutrient or dietary philosophy.
We need to look at the bigger picture: the diversity of our diet, the quality of our ingredients, the way food is prepared and the role of our digestive system in making use of what we eat.
At Symbiota, we believe there is something worth rediscovering in the traditional wisdom of food preparation.
From naturally fermented sauerkraut and kimchi to kombucha and water kefir, fermentation connects us with an age-old practice that has a meaningful place in modern food culture.
It's about eating real food, embracing diversity, nourishing our gut and making everyday choices that support our overall wellbeing.
Ancient wisdom. Modern living. And a little more appreciation for what happens between the soil and our plate.